On July 1, 2026, Virginia’s new firearm industry liability law took effect. Officially titled the “Virginia Firearm Industry Standards of Responsible Conduct,” it passed the General Assembly as HB 21 and was signed into law in April. In September, Attorney General Jay Jones gave it a dedicated enforcement team: the Firearms Accountability & Industry Responsibility Unit, or “FAIR Unit.”
Supporters call it accountability. We call it what it is: a legal weapon aimed at the businesses that serve Virginia’s law-abiding gun owners. Here’s what the law actually says, why we think it’s bad policy, and what it means for you.
What HB 21 Actually Does
HB 21 applies to every “firearm industry member” in Virginia. That’s anyone who sells, makes, distributes, imports or markets firearms, ammunition, parts or accessories here. It isn’t just big manufacturers. It covers local dealers like us, ammo sellers, and the shop down the road that sells holsters and optics.
The law puts two broad duties on all of us:
- Don’t “contribute to a public nuisance.” An industry member may not “knowingly create, maintain, or contribute to a public nuisance” through conduct that is unlawful or simply “unreasonable under the circumstances.”
- Have “reasonable controls.” Every industry member must put in place procedures and business practices meant to prevent sales to straw buyers, traffickers, prohibited persons, or anyone “at substantial risk,” along with preventing theft and other problems.
A violation of either duty is automatically treated as a public nuisance, and the person suing doesn’t have to prove the business intended to cause any harm.
Who can sue? The Attorney General, any county, city or town attorney, and private individuals who claim they were harmed. The remedies include court orders, “abatement” at the business’s own expense, restitution, compensatory and punitive damages, and the other side’s attorney fees. The Attorney General can also issue civil investigative demands, essentially subpoenas for a business’s records, whenever he has “reasonable cause to believe” a violation has occurred, is occurring, or is about to occur. That can happen before any lawsuit is filed.
Meet the “FAIR Unit”
On September 15, 2026, the Attorney General announced a dedicated unit inside his office to investigate the firearms industry and bring cases under HB 21. According to the state’s own job postings, it’s hiring civil litigators, prosecutors and investigators, led by a unit chief whose job is to design complex investigations and “build affirmative cases.” In other words, it’s a taxpayer-funded team whose full-time job is looking for reasons to take gun businesses to court.
We’re Already One of the Most Regulated Businesses in America
Here’s what gets lost in the press releases: selling firearms is already one of the most tightly controlled businesses in the country. As a licensed dealer, we:
- Hold a federal firearms license and are subject to ATF inspections.
- Run every firearm sale through ATF Form 4473 and a Virginia State Police background check.
- Log every firearm in and out of our inventory in a federally required record book.
- Keep those records for decades, available to ATF on request.
Selling to a straw buyer or a prohibited person is already a serious federal crime. So is trafficking. Responsible dealers already turn away sales that don’t feel right, every single week. HB 21 doesn’t create those rules. It hands government lawyers a vague new way to second-guess them after the fact.
It Won’t Stop Criminals
The people committing violent crimes generally aren’t walking into a licensed dealer, filling out a 4473 and passing a background check. In the U.S. Department of Justice’s most recent national survey of prison inmates, 90% of those who had a gun during their offense did not get it from a retail source. The largest share, 43%, got it off the street or the underground market.
If lawmakers want to reduce gun crime, the answer is to go after the criminals committing it: prosecute illegal possession, straw purchasing and trafficking cases fully, and keep violent repeat offenders off the street. Suing the businesses that are already following the law does none of that.
Imagine Applying This to Anything Else
When a drunk driver kills someone, nobody sues Ford, or the dealership that sold the car. When someone is stabbed, nobody sues the company that made the kitchen knife or the store that sold it. We hold the person who committed the crime responsible, because that’s who committed it.
That’s exactly the principle Congress wrote into federal law in 2005 with the Protection of Lawful Commerce in Arms Act (PLCAA), which generally bars lawsuits blaming gun makers and sellers for crimes committed by others. In 2025, the U.S. Supreme Court unanimously threw out Mexico’s lawsuit that tried to blame American gun companies for cartel violence.
Even the phrase “gun violence” puts the focus on the object instead of the person. Nobody talks about “car crash violence” or “knife violence.” The violence comes from the person, not the tool.
Laws like HB 21 are designed to get around that protection. PLCAA has an exception for businesses that knowingly violate a state law governing firearm sales or marketing. Write a broad enough state law full of terms like “unreasonable” and “reasonable controls,” and you’ve created a new way to drag businesses into court. It’s the same template national gun-control groups have pushed in state after state, and it singles out one lawful industry for treatment no other industry gets.
Let’s Talk About the Real Odds
To hear some lawmakers tell it, guns are the biggest threat Virginians face. The numbers say otherwise. Here are your lifetime odds of dying from various causes in the U.S., according to the National Safety Council’s most recent data (2024):
| Cause of death | Lifetime odds |
|---|---|
| Heart disease | 1 in 6 |
| Cancer | 1 in 7 |
| Accidental opioid overdose | 1 in 84 |
| Fall | 1 in 89 |
| Motor vehicle crash | 1 in 101 |
| Suicide with a gun | 1 in 156 |
| Gun assault (homicide) | 1 in 280 |
| Pedestrian incident | 1 in 492 |
| Drowning | 1 in 1,025 |
| Choking on food | 1 in 2,367 |
| Accidental gun discharge | 1 in 9,567 |
In other words, you’re more than 45 times more likely to die of heart disease than to be murdered with a gun, and roughly three times more likely to die from an accidental overdose, a fall or a car crash. You’re about four times more likely to choke to death on food than to die in a gun accident.
It’s also worth knowing that about 6 in 10 U.S. gun deaths are suicides, not crimes. That’s a mental health crisis, and it deserves real attention and real resources. Suing the store that sold a legal product to a law-abiding customer won’t fix it. If you or someone you know is struggling, call or text 988, the Suicide & Crisis Lifeline, any time.
And the guns politicians most want to ban are some of the least used in crime. In 2019, FBI data shows knives were used in 1,476 murders, hands, fists and feet in 600, and blunt objects like clubs and hammers in 397. Rifles of every kind, the category that includes the AR-15, were listed in 364.
We don’t pass laws making it easier to sue the companies that sell cars, ladders, kitchen knives or hammers, and we shouldn’t. Responsibility belongs to the person who misuses a product, not to everyone who legally makes or sells it. Firearms are the only product singled out this way, and that’s not about safety. It’s about guns.
Who Really Pays
The problem with a standard like “reasonable under the circumstances” is that nobody knows what it means until a judge decides, years later, after the fact. A large manufacturer has a legal department. A small, family-run shop like ours doesn’t. For a small business, just responding to a state investigation or defending one lawsuit can cost more than the business makes in a year, whether it did anything wrong or not. The process becomes the punishment.
The predictable result:
- Fewer dealers willing to open, or stay open, in Virginia.
- Out-of-state companies deciding Virginia customers aren’t worth the risk.
- Higher prices to cover insurance and legal costs.
- Law-abiding customers getting turned away because a business is afraid of how a sale might look in hindsight.
Many of us in the industry believe that’s not a side effect. It’s the point. When you can’t ban something outright, you can try to make it too risky and expensive for anyone to sell.
Will It Hold Up in Court?
Expect it to be challenged. Similar laws in New York, New Jersey and other states have been fought in court for years. It won’t be a quick fight, though: in June 2026 the Supreme Court declined to take up a challenge to New York’s version, leaving a lower-court ruling in place. The legal battle over these laws is far from over, and Virginia’s version will likely end up in court once the state starts using it.
What This Means for K3 Armory Customers
We’re not going anywhere. We follow every federal and Virginia law on every sale, and we always have.
Because of HB 21, every firearm transfer at K3 Armory now includes one extra page: our Compliance Acknowledgment and Customer Declaration. Along with your ATF Form 4473, Virginia SP-65 and Virginia State Police/NCIS background check, you’ll initial and sign a short form confirming that:
- You’re legally eligible to buy and own the firearm, and the information on your 4473 and SP-65 is true.
- You’re the actual buyer. It’s not a straw purchase.
- You understand the background check decision is made by the Virginia State Police and FBI, not by us.
- You know your responsibilities under Virginia law, including safe storage.
- You’re acquiring the firearm for lawful purposes, and what you do with it after the transfer is your responsibility.
It takes about a minute. It documents the safeguards we already follow on every sale, so that if anyone ever questions our “reasonable controls,” the record speaks for itself. If we ask a few more questions than you’re used to, now you know why. We’d rather take an extra minute with you than hand a state lawyer a reason to come after a small local business.
What You Can Do
- Contact your legislators. Find your delegate and senator with the General Assembly’s Who’s My Legislator tool and tell them how this law affects you.
- Support the groups fighting these laws in court, such as the Virginia Citizens Defense League (VCDL), Gun Owners of America (GOA), Firearms Policy Coalition (FPC) and others.
- Buy from local, law-abiding dealers. Small shops are the ones laws like this hit hardest.
For more on Virginia’s other new gun laws, see our posts on Virginia’s universal background check law and how to legally buy a gun online in Virginia. Questions about a purchase or transfer? Contact us or book an appointment.
This article is general information, not legal advice. Firearms laws change — as this page proves better than most — so consult the current statutes or a qualified attorney for your specific situation.
